EcoIvy.org

...because we care for Ivybridge

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
 EcoIvy Forum :: Talk to Anyone Else Who May Be Listening
Welcome Guest   [Register]  [Login]
 Subject :Nuclear Waste Incinerator.. 13-12-2009 04:09:30 
Anna
Joined: 16-11-2009 11:28:40
Posts: 20
Location: Devon
Whilst I was at the demonstration I heard a gentleman from Plymouth Unions speak about the proposed incinerator at Devonport, and that it would go onto incinerate low level nuclear waste from the dismantling of nuclear submarines; spreading the fall out ash all over the city, over thousands of people.

Like the proposed incinerator, I was blissfully unaware that nuclear submarines were decommissioned at Devonport. I was also unaware that the Dockyard is licensed to discharge low level nuclear waste.
The Committee on Radioactive Waste Management (CoRWM) in 2006 that the waste from Britain's nuclear reactors should be dealt with through deep burial. But instead they were cut up at Devonport.

I can’t find information online, but apparently the waste is then transported to bury at nuclear dumps around the UK.

Now a proposed incinerator at Devonport means that low level radioactive waste will no longer need to be transported to dump on someone else’ doorstep such as Drigg in Cumbria, instead it can be burned here in Plymouth and the fall out impact will be noticed by all.


Should nuclear waste should be transported at all as it poses to great a risk to human health is it fair to dump it on someone else’s door step either, why should it go anywhere? Why was it created at all?
If it needs to go anywhere it should be buried deep underground, and no more ever created again. Or perhaps, it should go into the back yard of the people who created it? Was that our government? Or was it us, the people, for standing by and allowing our government to create it?
If we are going to create more and more nuclear waste, surely we need to find a solution we all agree on first? Before having dirty nuclear waste, that nobody wants to have on their doorstep.


I really don’t want nuclear waste to be burned anywhere ever. But just as landfill is running out, so is nuclear landfill.












The following accidents are just some of those that have occurred in recent years:
25/03/09 radioactive waste escaped HMS Turbulent at Devonport
11/08 280 litres radioactive waste went into River Tamar
10/05 another leak
05/08 two spillages, so severe that Environment Agency threatened legal action


A quote from Linda Gilroy MP - her website blog:
Devonport and the Incinerator Proposal
A number have people have asked me for my view on this. I have issued the following statement today,
"This is not a good idea. There is no direct relevance to the work that takes place in the dockyard or the naval base, all of which is highly skilled and complex. I struggle to see how an incinerator would bring worthwhile numbers of quality jobs to Devonport or support our existing economic sectors. However in common with other local residents I can see that it would almost certainly bring increased traffic and noise to what is a very already busy area. I think the proposed site at Lee Mill is the most suitable choice. There is more space and a lower population density, meaning it is well suited to cope with increased traffic. I will be working with councillors and local residents to advance this argument."

http://www.thisisplymouth.co.uk/news/Nuclear-sub-work-hazardous/article-1598992-detail/article.html
http://www.thisisplymouth.co.uk/news/SCANDAL-N-SUB-COVER/article-743237-detail/article.html
IP Logged
 Subject :Re:Nuclear Waste Incinerator.. 13-12-2009 15:35:58 
frankie
Joined: 05-11-2009 13:20:54
Posts: 40
Location
Anna, this is just terrible. Terrible. You picked a smiley with tears - and that is how I feel.

Also, when are Linda Gilroy and Gary Streeter both going to wake up and get the message? Incineration is not a solution - and if not for us, not for them either!
Why to politicians have to be so spineless that they cannot stand on truth and argue for the sake of mankind and not simply their own interests?
The issue of an incinerator has been in the air for years now - little known to us, but very much known to them.
What did either of them do to shape policy for a long term greener solution?

Zilch, diddly squat, that's what!
IP Logged
 Subject :Re:Nuclear Waste Incinerator.. 13-12-2009 16:48:18 
Anna
Joined: 16-11-2009 11:28:40
Posts: 20
Location: Devon
Absolutely, I really don't think nuclear submarines should be decomissioned 400 metres from a primary school.
Seriously, what are the politicians doing in this county?

I can see these nuclear items must be dealt with somehwere, but I think they should be buried, not burnt. It doesn't matter if it's over a city of people, or just a small village of a few hundred people, nobody should have to deal with a risk of radiation where they live.


Devon is too lovely to let this happen to. I've only been here for less than a year, but there is no way it should be turned into a toxic dump, it's cleanest place in Britian!


I don't think people will want to come on holiday to Devon and Cornwall anymore, when the cream tea's glow in the dark and thier children end up with cancer from swimming in the sea. Forget about wearing sunscreen, you'll be needing a lead suit and a gas mask for your typical British holiday in a few years time if these plans continue!
IP Logged
 Subject :Re:Nuclear Waste Incinerator.. 14-12-2009 07:29:49 
frankie
Joined: 05-11-2009 13:20:54
Posts: 40
Location
Never mind the holidays, not sure I'll be wanting to live here either. I was thinking this morning about how terrible it will be if the incinerator does go ahead. I feel it would be a total violation of our rights to change the quality of the very air we breathe against our will and to use our council tax to create a facility that would pump out thousands of tonnes of C02 threatening the futures of all our children.

I was reading the the Herald this morning (did you see our article? we got some great coverage today!) that South West Water were recently placed at the top of the Evironment Agency's water company polluters prosecution league table - despite charging us the highest water rates in the country. South West Water are Viridor's sister company, both owned by the Pennon Group.
IP Logged
Page # 


Powered by ccBoard


Email Updates

Add your email here to receive email updates about this issue. Your email won't be used for any other purpose and won't be passed on to anyone else.
Name:
Email:

Login

Please log in here to post items to the forum and submit links or articles to be included on this site. Please get involved, we need your input!

Polls

Are you satisfied that the public has been fully consulted regarding the plans to build an incinerator at the New England Quarry?
 
Do you think an incinerator is a good solution for Devon's waste?
 
Are you mostly in support of Viridor's plans to build an incinerator at this location?
 

Newsflash

Please sign the following petition:

http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/c02incineration/


Please also post the link to any UK forum or pressure group that is concerned about C02 emissions or incineration. Thanks!